Moscow, Russian Federation
UDK 50 Общие вопросы математических и естественных наук
UDK 51 Математика
GRNTI 29.15 Ядерная физика
The energy obtained at nuclear power plants is considered environmentally friendly, so an increase in the number of nuclear power plants is inevitable both in Russia and abroad. But the memory of accidents and incidents at nuclear power plants, their causes and destructive consequences should force all responsible participants in the process to follow the basic principles of defense in depth and safety culture. Analysis of the factors considered in the article indicates that the approach to the implementation of the principle of safety culture on the part of officials of the State Atomic Energy Corporation Rosatom and the world's second operating organization, Rosenergoatom Concern JSC, is subject to emasculation to the greatest extent. This indicates that the lessons of past accidents at nuclear power plants are not fully absorbed in the nuclear industry of the Russian Federation and the existing bureaucratic nihilism in relation to the fulfillment of the requirements of federal norms and rules requires urgent overcoming.
nuclear power plants, nuclear power plants, federal norms and rules, safety deficiencies, equipment and pipelines of systems important to safety, non-destructive testing of the state of metal, non-destructive testing systems, certification testing of non-destructive testing systems, the concept of leak before destruction
1. NEI. The lingering ghost of Chernobyl. 9 July 2019. https://www.neimagazine.com/features/featurethe-lingering-ghost-of-chernobyl-7304114/
2. IAEA. Nuclear Power Reactors in the World. Reference Data Series No.2. 2020.
3. A. Rising, J. Lindbarg. Nuclear delivers a stronger tomorrow // Nuclear Engineering international, September 2020.
4. Avarii i incidenty na atomnyh elektrostanciyah. Uchebnoe posobie pod obschey redakciey d.f.-m.n., professora S.P.Solov'eva. Obninsk, IATE, 1992, 300 s.
5. Kanal'nyy yadernyy energeticheskiy reaktor RBMK / Pod obsch. red. Yu.M. Cherkashova; otv. red. Yu.M. Nikitin, I.A. Stenbok. Glava 13 - Moskva: GUP NIKIET, 2006 (Lyubercy (Mosk. obl.): PIK VINITI). - 631 s.
6. T. Narabayasi (T. NARABAYASHI). Ispol'zovanie opyta, poluchennogo posle avarii na AES «FUKUSIMA-DAYIChI», dlya obespecheniya bezopasnosti AES vo vsem mire // Trudy 8-oy mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-tehnicheskoy konferencii «Bezopasnost', effektivnost' i ekonomika atomnoy energetiki» (MNTK-2012), 23–25 maya 2012, Moskva, Rossiya.
7. Nuclear Engineering International, vol.65, No.791 (May 2020), p.39 https://secure.viewer.zmags.com/publication/4d4161a2#/4d4161a2/36
8. A.I. Arzhaev, S.V. Evropin, V.A. Kiselev, V.O. Mahanev, A.A. Petrov, A.A. Potapov, V.A Savchenko, G.N. Saprykin. Obespechenie bezopasnoy ekspluatacii elementov KMPC energoblokov AES s reaktorami RBMK-1000 na baze koncepcii «isklyuchenie razryvov» (IAEA-CN-114--21p) // Doklad na Mezhdunarodnoy konferencii MAGATE «50 let atomnoy energetike», 28 iyunya – 2 iyulya 2004, Obninsk, Rossiya.
9. A. Arzhaev ,V. Baldin , S. Evropin , A. Ekimovski , A. Petrov , V. Savchenko , G. Saprykine. Main results of life extension concept application at LNPP Unit 1 // International Journal of Nuclear Energy Science and Technology, No 1(4), pp.274-279 (2005).
10. Vikin V.A., Zhbannikov V.V., Prytkov A.N., Slivkin M.P. Ocenka sostoyaniya metalla i svarnyh soedineniy oborudovaniya i truboprovodov I kontura RU VVER440 I pokoleniya v period sverh proektnogo sroka ekspluatacii Novovoronezhskoy AES // Trudy 10-oy Mezhdunarodnaya konferenciya «Problemy materialovedeniya pri proektirovanii, izgotovlenii i ekspluatacii oborudovaniya AES», 7-9 oktyabrya 2008, Sankt-Peterburg, Rossiya.
11. V.G. Asmolov Obespechenie bezopasnosti i povyshenie effektivnosti atomnoy energetiki Rossii // Soobschenie na plenarnom zasedanii 9-oy mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-tehnicheskoy konferencii «Bezopasnost', effektivnost' i ekonomika atomnoy energetiki» (MNTK-2014), 23-24 maya, 2014, Moskva, Rossiya.
12. A.V. Shutikov. Blizhnesrochnye plany Koncerna po realizacii strategii razvitiya yadernoy energetiki // // Soobschenie na plenarnom zasedanii 11-oy mezhdunarodnoy nauchno-tehnicheskoy konferencii «Bezopasnost', effektivnost' i ekonomika atomnoy energetiki» (MNTK-2018), 23-24 maya, 2018, Moskva, Rossiya.
13. NP-017-18.Osnovnye trebovaniya k prodleniyu sroka ekspluatacii bloka atomnoy stancii. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/542622324
14. Shutikov A.V. Rol' AO OKB «Gidropress» v reshenii osnovnyh zadach AO «Koncern Rosenergoatom» // 10-ya Mezhdunarodnaya nauchno-tehnicheskaya konferenciya «Obespechenie bezopasnosti AES s VVER» (MNTK-2017), 16-19 maya 2017, Podol'sk, Rossiya.
15. PNAE G-7-008-89. Pravila ustroystva i bezopasnoy ekspluatacii oborudovaniya i truboprovodov atomnyh energeticheskih ustanovok. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/1200044519
16. NP-089-15. Pravila ustroystva i bezopasnoy ekspluatacii oborudovaniya i truboprovodov atomnyh energeticheskih ustanovok. 2015.
17. NP-089-15 (red. ot 19.11.2019). Pravila ustroystva i bezopasnoy ekspluatacii oborudovaniya i truboprovodov atomnyh energeticheskih ustanovok. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/420329010
18. NP-084-15. Pravila kontrolya osnovnogo metalla, svarnyh soedineniy i naplavlennyh poverhnostey pri ekspluatacii oborudovaniya, truboprovodov i drugih elementov atomnyh stanciy. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/420324294
19. PNAE G-7-009-89. Oborudovanie i truboprovody atomnyh energeticheskih ustanovok. Svarka i naplavka. Osnovnye polozheniya (s Izmeneniem N 1). http://docs.cntd.ru/document/1200036947
20. NP-104-18. Svarka i naplavka oborudovaniya i truboprovodov atomnyh energeticheskih ustanovok. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/551789830
21. PNAE G-7-010-89. Oborudovanie i truboprovody atomnyh energeticheskih ustanovok. Svarnye soedineniya i naplavki. Pravila kontrolya. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/1200036948
22. NP-105-18. Pravila kontrolya metalla oborudovaniya i truboprovodov atomnyh energeticheskih ustanovok pri izgotovlenii i montazhe. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/551789828
23. PNAE G-7-002-86. Normy rascheta na prochnost' oborudovaniya i truboprovodov atomnyh energeticheskih ustanovok. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/1200037730 i http://docs.cntd.ru/document/1200042824
24. Zakupka №161013/0513/1736. Pravo zaklyucheniya dogovora na Peresmotr federal'nyh norm i pravil «Normy rascheta na prochnost' oborudovaniya i truboprovodov atomnyh energeticheskih ustanovok» PNAEG-7-002-86. http://www.zakupki.rosatom.ru/16101305131736.
25. NP-001-97 (PNAE G-01-011-97). Obschie polozheniya obespecheniya bezopasnosti atomnyh stanciy OPB-88/97. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/1200048646
26. NP-001-15. Obschie polozheniya obespecheniya bezopasnosti atomnyh stanciy. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/420329007
27. PNAE G-1-024-90. Pravila yadernoy bezopasnosti reaktornyh ustanovok atomnyh stanciy (PBYa RU AS-89). https://files.stroyinf.ru/Data1/8/8262/index.htm
28. NP-082-07. Pravila yadernoy bezopasnosti reaktornyh ustanovok atomnyh stanciy. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/902083695
29. PNAE G-01-036-95 (NP-006-98). Trebovaniya k soderzhaniyu otcheta po obosnovaniyu bezopasnosti AS s reaktorami tipa VVER. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/1200054204
30. NP-006-16. Trebovaniya k soderzhaniyu otcheta po obosnovaniyu bezopasnosti bloka atomnoy stancii s reaktorom tipa VVER. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/456052890
31. NP-096-15. Trebovaniya k upravleniyu resursom oborudovaniya i truboprovodov atomnyh stanciy. Osnovnye polozheniya. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/420311970
32. NP-017-2000. Osnovnye trebovaniya k prodleniyu sroka ekspluatacii bloka atomnoy stancii. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/1200034210
33. NP-071-18. Pravila ocenki sootvetstviya produkcii, dlya kotoroy ustanavlivayutsya trebovaniya, svyazannye s obespecheniem bezopasnosti v oblasti ispol'zovaniya atomnoy energii, a takzhe processov ee proektirovaniya (vklyuchaya izyskaniya), proizvodstva, stroitel'stva, montazha, naladki, ekspluatacii, hraneniya, perevozki, realizacii, utilizacii i zahoroneniya. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/542618368
34. NP-071-06. Pravila ocenki sootvetstviya oborudovaniya, komplektuyuschih, materialov i polufabrikatov, postavlyaemyh na ob'ekty ispol'zovaniya atomnoy energii. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/1200046475
35. NP-071-06 (s izm. ot 16.03.2018). Pravila ocenki sootvetstviya oborudovaniya, komplektuyuschih, materialov i polufabrikatov, postavlyaemyh na ob'ekty ispol'zovaniya atomnoy energii.
36. IAEA. Methodology for qualification of in-service inspection systems for WWER nuclear power plants. IAEA-EBP-WWER-11, 1998.
37. ENIQ Report nr.12. ENIQ Glossary, Issue 2. Eur18102en, 1999.
38. ENIQ Report nr.31. European methodology for qualification of non-destructive testing, Issue 3. Eur22906en, 2007.
39. Postanovlenie Pravitel'stva Rossiyskoy Federacii ot 23.04.2013 №362 «Ob osobennostyah tehnicheskogo regulirovaniya v chasti razrabotki i ustanovleniya gosudarstvennymi zakazchikami, federal'nymi organami ispolnitel'noy vlasti, upolnomochennymi v oblasti gosudarstvennogo upravleniya ispol'zovaniem atomnoy energii i gosudarstvennogo regulirovaniya bezopasnosti pri ispol'zovanii atomnoy energii, i Gosudarstvennoy korporaciey po atomnoy energii "Rosatom" obyazatel'nyh trebovaniy v otnoshenii produkcii, dlya kotoroy ustanavlivayutsya trebovaniya, svyazannye s obespecheniem bezopasnosti v oblasti ispol'zovaniya atomnoy energii, a takzhe processov proektirovaniya (vklyuchaya izyskaniya), proizvodstva, stroitel'stva, montazha, naladki, ekspluatacii, hraneniya, perevozki, realizacii, utilizacii i zahoroneniya ukazannoy produkcii» http://publication.pravo.gov.ru/Document/View/0001201304260009.;
40. Postanovlenie Pravitel'stva Rossiyskoy Federacii ot 12.07.2016 №669 «Ob utverzhdeniya Polozheniya o standartizacii v otnoshenii produkcii (rabot, uslug), dlya kotoroy ustanavlivayutsya trebovaniya, svyazannye s obespecheniem bezopasnosti v oblasti ispol'zovaniya atomnoy energii, a takzhe processov i inyh ob'ektov standartizacii, svyazannyh s takoy produkciey» http://publication.pravo.gov.ru/Document/View/0001201607140004.
41. Postanovlenie Pravitel'stva Rossiyskoy Federacii ot 15.06.2016 №544 «Ob osobennostyah ocenki sootvetstviya produkcii, dlya kotoroy ustanavlivayutsya trebovaniya, svyazannye s obespecheniem bezopasnosti v oblasti ispol'zovaniya atomnoy energii, a takzhe processov ee proektirovaniya (vklyuchaya izyskaniya), proizvodstva, stroitel'stva, montazha, naladki, ekspluatacii, hraneniya, perevozki, realizacii, utilizacii i zahoroneniya» http://publication.pravo.gov.ru/Document/View/0001201606170022.
42. Postanovlenie Pravitel'stva Rossiyskoy Federacii ot 20.07.2013 №612 «Ob akkreditacii v oblasti ispol'zovaniya atomnoy energii» http://publication.pravo.gov.ru/Document/View/0001201307290007.
43. GOST R 50.04.07-2018. Sistema ocenki sootvetstviya v oblasti ispol'zovaniya atomnoy energii. Ocenka sootvetstviya v forme ispytaniy. Attestacionnye ispytaniya sistem nerazrushayuschego kontrolya. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/1200158657
44. GOST R 1.2-2016. Standartizaciya v Rossiyskoy Federacii. Standarty nacional'nye Rossiyskoy Federacii. Pravila razrabotki, utverzhdeniya, obnovleniya, vneseniya popravok i otmeny /deystvoval na moment vvedeniya v deystvie standarta [43].
45. GOST R 50.05.16-2018. «Sistema ocenki sootvetstviya v oblasti ispol'zovaniya atomnoy energii. Ocenka sootvetstviya v forme kontrolya. Nerazrushayuschiy kontrol'. Metrologicheskoe obespechenie» (vveden v deystve s marta 2019 g. kak GOST R 50.05.16-2019).
46. Tehnicheskiy komitet po standartizacii TK322 «Atomnaya tehnika». Protokol №73-MK/2018-Pr ot 27.09.2018 g. Zasedanie po obsuzhdeniyu predlozheniy po vneseniyu izmeneniy v GOST R 50.04.07-2018 «Sistema ocenki sootvetstviya v oblasti ispol'zovaniya atomnoy energii. Ocenka sootvetstviya v forme ispytaniy. Attestacionnye ispytaniya sistem nerazrushayuschego kontrolya» i voprosa utverzhdeniya proekta proekt standarta GOST R «Sistema ocenki sootvetstviya v oblasti ispol'zovaniya atomnoy energii. Ocenka sootvetstviya v forme kontrolya. Nerazrushayuschiy kontrol'. Metrologicheskoe obespechenie».
47. AO IK «ASE». Protokol zasedaniya Ob'edinennogo nauchno-tehnicheskogo soveta ot 23.08.2018 g. №40-1.2S/156-Pr. Prilozhenie 3. Arzhaev A.I. Predlozheniya po standartizacii podhodov k obosnovaniyu koncepcii TPR (chast' 1).
48. IAEA. Basic Safety Principles for Nuclear Power Plants 75-INSAG-3 Rev. 1. A Report by the International Nuclear Safety Group. INSAG Series No. 12 / IAEA – V.: IAEA, 1999 – 97 p.
49. AO «Koncern Rosenergoatom». Razrabotka tehnicheskogo zadaniya, provedenie ispytaniy i usloviya primeneniya sredstv i metodik nerazrushayuschego kontrolya na atomnyh stanciyah. Trebovaniya. RD EO 0487-2005, 2005.
50. AO «Koncern Rosenergoatom». Razrabotka tehnicheskogo zadaniya, provedenie ispytaniy i usloviya primeneniya sredstv i metodik nerazrushayuschego kontrolya na atomnyh stanciyah. Trebovaniya. RD EO 1.1.2.25.0487-2015, 2015.
51. FGAOU VO SPbPU, OOO «NPO «DIAPROK». O deficitah primeneniya koncepcii «Tech' pered razrusheniem» k konturu teplonositelya reaktora blokov atomnyh stanciy raznyh pokoleniy. Nauchno-tehnicheskiy otchet, 2018.
52. GOST R 58328-18. Truboprovody atomnyh stanciy. Koncepciya «tech' pered razrusheniem».
53. RD 95 10547-99 Rukovodstvo po primeneniyu koncepcii bezopasnosti tech' pered razrusheniem k truboprovodam AEU. R-TPR-01-99.
54. U.S. NRC, «Leak-Before-Break Evaluation Procedures», Standard Review Plan (SRP), Section 3.6.3, NUREG-0800.
55. H. Schulz. The Evolution of the Break Preclusion Concept for Nuclear Power Plants in Germany. Proceedings of the Seminar on Leak Before Break in Reactor Piping and Vessels. Lyons, France, 9-11 October 1995.
56. Antonov M.I., Arzhaev A.A., Arzhaev A.I., Ershov G.A., Kalyutik A.A., Karyakin Yu.E., Mahanev V.O. Problemnye voprosy obespecheniya celostnosti truboprovodov i korpusov oborudovaniya AS. // 11-ya Mezhdunarodnaya nauchno-tehnicheskaya konferenciya «Obespechenie bezopasnosti AES s VVER» (MNTK-2019, g. Podol'sk, Rossiya , 21-24 maya 2019 g.).
57. AO «Koncern Rosenergoatom». Rukovodstvo po primeneniyu koncepcii bezopasnosti tech' pered razrusheniem k truboprovodam deystvuyuschih AEU. RD EO 1.1.2.05.0939-2013.
58. AO «Koncern Rosenergoatom». Koncepciya bezopasnosti «tech' pered razrusheniem» dlya kontura teplonositelya atomnyh stanciy. RD EO 1.1.2.05.0939-2016.
59. IAEA. Mitigation of intergranular stress corrosion cracking in RBMK reactors. Final report of the programme's steering committee. IAEA-EBP-IGSCC, 2002.
60. Nuclear Safety Standards Commission (KTA), Verification Analysis for Rupture Preclusion for Pressure Retaining Components in Nuclear Power Plants., Safety Standard KTA 3206, 2014.
61. FGAOU VO «Sankt-Peterburgskiy politehnicheskiy universitet Petra Velikogo», OOO «NPO «DIAPROK». O deficitah primeneniya koncepcii «tech' pered razrusheniem» k konturu teplonositelya reaktora blokov atomnyh stanciy raznyh pokoleniy. Nauchno-tehnicheskoy otchet, sentyabr' 2018g.
62. NP-010-16. Pravila ustroystva i ekspluatacii lokalizuyuschih sistem bezopasnosti atomnyh stanciy (s izmeneniyami na 17 yanvarya 2017 goda). http://docs.cntd.ru/document/420341403.
63. GK «Rosatom». Programma provedeniya tehnicheskih seminarov «Proektirovanie truboprovodov v sootvetstvii s ASME BPVC i EN 13480» i «Praktika primeneniya koncepcii «Tech'-pered-razrusheniem» na AES amerikanskogo i francuzskogo dizayna» v period 4-6 iyunya 2019, Sankt-Peterburg, Rossiya.
64. SSR-2/1. Bezopasnost' atomnyh elektrostanciy: proektirovanie. Normy bezopasnosti MAGATE, 2012.
65. SSR-2/1, rev 1. Bezopasnost' atomnyh elektrostanciy: proektirovanie. Normy bezopasnosti MAGATE, 2016.
66. AO «Atomkomplekt». Zakupka http://zakupki.rosatom.ru/1205251065154.
67. AO «Atomkomplekt». Zakupka http://zakupki.rosatom.ru/1603141065056.
68. AO «Atomkomplekt». Zakupka http://zakupki.rosatom.ru/1509251065277.
69. AO «Atomkomplekt». Zakupka http://zakupki.rosatom.ru/1512011065368.
70. A.A.Aref'ev. «Ocenka sootvetstviya sistem nerazrushayuschego kontrolya sostoyaniya metalla oborudovaniya, truboprovodov i drugih elementov AS v ramkah GOST R 50.04.07-2018». Prilozhenie k protokolu №73-MK/2018-Pr ot 27.09.2018 g. [46].
71. Pis'mo OOO «NPO «DIAPROK» ish.№14-04/135 ot 18.06.2020 v adres TK 322 «Atomnaya tehnika».
