Causing Harm in the Healthcare Delivery as the Provision of Services that Do Not Meet Safety Requirements

Arseniy Bimbinov

doi:doi:10.12737/jrl.2022.077

UDC 34

Causing Harm in the Healthcare Delivery as the Provision of Services that Do Not Meet Safety Requirements

Published в Journal of Russian Law · Volume 26, Issue 7, 2023 · Pages 1–1 · Rubrics: Criminal Law and Criminology

DOI 10.12737/jrl.2022.077

Received: 06.01.2023 Accepted: 06.01.2023 Published: 06.01.2023

Authors

Arseniy Bimbinov ¹

1 Kutafin Moscow State Law Academy’s (criminal law, associate professor)
Russian Federation

ABSTRACT

V processe pravoprimenitel'noy deyatel'nosti po ugolovnym delam, vozbuzhdennym po faktu nenadlezhaschego okazaniya medicinskoy pomoschi, voznikaet bol'shoe kolichestvo voprosov, bol'shinstvo iz kotoryh reshaetsya na osnove obschih pravil kvalifikacii prestupleniy i naznacheniya za nih nakazaniy. Osobnyakom stoit problema razgranicheniya sostavov prestupleniy, sostoyaschih v prichinenii smerti ili tyazhkogo vreda zdorov'yu vsledstvie nenadlezhaschego ispolneniya licom svoih professional'nyh obyazannostey (ch. 2 st. 109 i st. 118 UK RF) i okazanii uslug, ne otvechayuschih trebovaniyam bezopasnosti, v tom chisle povlekshih po neostorozhnosti prichinenie tyazhkogo vreda zdorov'yu libo smert' cheloveka (st. 238 UK RF). Avtorom predprinyata popytka ustanovit' kriterii razgranicheniya ukazannyh sostavov prestupleniy primenitel'no k sluchayam prichineniya vreda pri okazanii medicinskoy pomoschi. Ustanovlennye kriterii mogut blagopriyatno otrazit'sya na sudebno-sledstvennoy praktike, vklyuchaya obespechenie ee edinoobraziya v chasti kvalifikacii prestupleniy. Issledovanie vklyuchalo izuchenie opublikovannyh nauchnyh rabot, posvyaschennyh problematike ugolovnoy otvetstvennosti medicinskih rabotnikov, statistiki vrachebnoy prestupnosti, uyasnenie i sopostavlenie norm deystvuyuschego zakonodatel'stva, a takzhe analiz dostupnyh materialov ugolovnyh del, vozbuzhdennyh vvidu nenadlezhaschego okazaniya medicinskoy pomoschi. Ustanovleno, chto osnovnym kriteriem razgranicheniya sostavov prestupleniy, predusmotrennyh st. 109, 118 i 238 UK RF, yavlyaetsya harakteristika ob'ekta posyagatel'stva. Ob'ektom okazaniya uslug, ne otvechayuschih trebovaniyam bezopasnosti, yavlyaetsya zdorov'e naseleniya, kotoroe predstavlyaet soboy obschestvennye otnosheniya, skladyvayuschiesya po povodu pravil'noy organizacii zdravoohraneniya, napravlennoy na obespechenie blagopoluchiya grazhdan v nepersonificirovannom vide, poetomu postradat' ukazannye otnosheniya mogut lish' pri sistemnom haraktere medicinskih narusheniy, kogda suschestvuet ugroza zhizni ili zdorov'yu neopredelennogo kruga lic.

KEYWORDS

yatrogeniya vrach medicinskiy rabotnik kvalifikaciya prestupleniy ugolovnaya otvetstvennost' prichinenie smerti medicinskaya oshibka vrachebnaya oshibka

Information Text References

Authors:

1. Kutafin Moscow State Law Academy’s (criminal law, associate professor)

Russian Federation

Type:

Article

Pages:

from 1 to 1

Status:

Published

Subject area:

UDC 34

Language:

Russian

Keywords:

yatrogeniya, vrach, medicinskiy rabotnik, kvalifikaciya prestupleniy, ugolovnaya otvetstvennost', prichinenie smerti, medicinskaya oshibka, vrachebnaya oshibka

Text

No data

References

1. No data

Causing Harm in the Healthcare Delivery as the Provision of Services that Do Not Meet Safety Requirements

Confirmation

Регистрация